This shootout pits five iconic analog delay pedals against each other: the MXR Carbon Copy, Way Huge Aqua Puss, Boss DM-2W, Moog MF104M, and Electro-Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man. Each pedal boasts a unique sonic character, offering a diverse range of delay tones from subtle slapback to expansive, swirling soundscapes. We'll delve into the strengths and weaknesses of each, exploring their ease of use, tonal characteristics, and overall versatility. Whether you're a seasoned guitarist or just starting your pedalboard journey, this comparison will help you navigate the world of analog delay and find the perfect pedal to match your playing style.This in-depth review will examine each pedal's features, sound quality, and suitability for various musical genres. We’ll analyze the nuances of their delay times, modulation effects, and overall feel, helping you understand how each pedal contributes to the sonic tapestry of your music. Prepare to discover which analog delay reigns supreme, offering the perfect blend of classic tone and modern versatility to elevate your playing.
Pros And Cons
- Nice modulation
- Long enough delay time (around 600 milliseconds)
- Clock noise at longer delay times
- Digital artifacts from the clock at longer delay times
- Standard and custom modes
- Custom mode sounds nice and clear
- Can control rate with expression pedal
- Direct out for stereo
- Very bright repeats
- Nice for slapback sound
- Highest delay time is 330 milliseconds (can't go super long)
- Affordable
- Sounds good
- Nice modulation
- No tap tempo
Read more: Top 5 Guitar Chorus Pedals You Need
MXR Carbon Copy: Affordable Excellence
The MXR Carbon Copy was my first delay pedal, and it remains a favorite. Its simple operation and warm tone are perfect for beginners and experienced players alike. The subtle modulation adds a touch of character without being overwhelming. It lacks tap tempo, but its affordability and pleasant sound make up for it.
The Carbon Copy excels in creating classic slapback delays and subtle rhythmic textures. While not as feature-rich as some others, its core functionality is executed flawlessly, making it a highly versatile workhorse for any guitarist's pedalboard.
Way Huge Aqua Puss: Bright and Snappy
The Way Huge Aqua Puss is known for its bright, snappy repeats. Its maximum delay time is limited to 330 milliseconds, making it ideal for slapback and shorter rhythmic effects. The bright character of the repeats cuts through the mix very effectively, making it easy to hear over other instruments.
Despite its short delay time, the Aqua Puss's unique tonal characteristics are perfect for players who favor punchy, forward-sounding delays. Its simplicity and immediate response make it highly appealing to those seeking a no-frills, direct approach to analog delay.
Boss DM-2W Waza Craft: Versatile and Classic
The Boss DM-2W Waza Craft offers both standard and custom modes. Standard mode emulates the original DM-2, providing a shorter delay time and vintage voicing. Custom mode expands the delay time and offers a cleaner, more modern sound.
The DM-2W is a fantastic blend of classic warmth and contemporary features. Its ability to switch between vintage and modern delay tones is a significant plus. The inclusion of expression pedal control adds another dimension of flexibility, solidifying its position as a very useful analog delay.
Moog MF104M: Dark and Ambient
The Moog MF104M offers 'short' and 'long' delay modes, each with distinct characteristics. The short mode provides a more traditional delay sound, while the long mode generates beautifully dark, ambient repeats with a unique, underwater quality.
This pedal stands out with its ability to craft atmospheric textures. The long mode is particularly striking, offering a vast soundscape of lush and immersive delays. The Moog excels at creating ambient soundscapes ideal for more experimental music.
Electro-Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man: Legendary Modulation
The Electro-Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man is a legendary analog delay known for its rich modulation and long delay times (around 600 milliseconds). The longer delay times introduce some tape-like characteristics, including a noticeable clock noise at greater delay times, but that's part of its distinctive charm.
The DMM's modulation is exceptional, offering both vibrato and chorus effects. Its ability to create lush, swirling soundscapes is unmatched by the other pedals in this shootout. This iconic pedal is essential for anyone exploring classic, spacious delay tones.
Overall Conclusions and Comparison
Each delay pedal in this shootout offers a unique flavor. The MXR Carbon Copy is affordable and versatile, ideal for beginners. The Way Huge Aqua Puss excels at bright, snappy repeats. The Boss DM-2W is a flexible classic with modern updates. The Moog MF104M shines with dark, ambient tones, while the Electro-Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man is a legendary choice for lush modulation and spacious delays.
The best choice depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you need a simple, affordable delay, the MXR Carbon Copy is an excellent option. For bright, punchy repeats, consider the Aqua Puss. For a versatile, classic-style delay, the DM-2W is a great choice. Those looking for dark and ambient tones should choose the Moog MF104M. Finally, for legendary modulation and expansive soundscapes, the Electro-Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man is the ultimate winner.