Finding the perfect guitar pick can feel like a quest. This shootout dives deep into the sonic landscapes offered by a variety of picks, helping you navigate the world of tone and feel. We’ll be comparing some of the most talked-about picks on the market, from the renowned Blue Chip TAD 60s in both rounded and standard bevels, to the unique warmth of an antique tortoiseshell pick, the balanced attack of the John Pierce Fast Turtle, and the affordable versatility of the Dunlop Tortex. We'll also explore the precision of the Wegen Bluegrass pick and the rich tones of the Dunlop Jazz pick. Get ready to discover the pick that unlocks your true playing potential.This detailed comparison goes beyond simple descriptions; we'll analyze each pick's attack, tone, and overall playing experience. We'll explore the subtle nuances that separate a bright, articulate sound from a warm, resonant one. Whether you’re a seasoned professional or just starting your musical journey, this shootout will provide valuable insights and help you make an informed decision on your next pick purchase. Prepare to embark on a sonic journey as we uncover the secrets behind these exceptional picks.
Pros And Cons
- Affordable
- Good for light strumming
- Round attack
- Good sound
Read more: 5 Best Celluloid Guitar Picks You Need to Try
Blue Chip TAD 60: The Rounded Bevel
My first pick in this shootout is the Blue Chip TAD 60 with its three-round, rounded bevels. I've used the TAD 60s for a while, but wanted to compare the rounded bevel to the standard speed bevel.
The rounded bevels give a distinctly round attack on the strings, offering a softer, warmer tone compared to picks with sharper edges. This is noticeable during both strumming and flatpicking.
The sound is full and rich, making it ideal for various playing styles. The rounded edge provides a comfortable playing experience even during extended sessions.
Blue Chip TAD 60: Standard Speed Bevel
Next, we have another Blue Chip TAD 60, but this one features the standard speed bevel with sharpened corners. This is a more common design among guitar picks.
The difference in sound is immediately apparent. The sharpened corners provide a brighter, more articulate tone, compared to the softer sound of the rounded bevel.
This pick is more responsive to aggressive playing techniques, producing a crisp and precise attack. It might be preferable for those seeking a more cutting tone.
Antique Tortoiseshell Pick
This unique pick is crafted from genuine antique tortoiseshell material, offering a truly one-of-a-kind playing experience. This pick, obtained from a friend, has a rich history.
Despite being the same thickness as the Blue Chip TAD 60, the tortoiseshell pick boasts a distinct, warm and resonant tone. It's a highly sought-after piece and hard to find.
Its unique material and age contribute to its exceptional sound, showcasing an unmatched depth and warmth. This pick is truly a collector's item.
John Pierce Fast Turtle Pick
The John Pierce Fast Turtle pick, in a medium thickness, provides a slightly thicker and rounder attack than the tortoiseshell. It offers a different tonal character.
While sharing similarities with the Blue Chip and tortoiseshell picks in terms of warmth and roundness, the Fast Turtle possesses its unique sonic signature. It's slightly more aggressive.
This pick offers a balance between warmth and articulation, making it versatile for various playing styles. The medium thickness provides good control and feedback.
Dunlop Tortex .60 Pick
For a significant change of pace, the Dunlop Tortex .60 is a much thinner and more affordable option. I used these early in my playing career.
Its thinness leads to a lighter feel and a brighter, more responsive tone. This is ideal for light strumming patterns and subtle fingerstyle techniques.
While not as warm or full as the thicker picks, the Tortex .60 provides a clean and articulate sound suitable for certain genres. It is great for quick picking.
Wegen Bluegrass Pick
The Wegen Bluegrass pick, in 1.4 size, is slightly thinner than the Blue Chips but shares a similar tone profile. The absence of holes makes for cleaner tone.
It offers a good balance between warmth, clarity, and attack. The pick's design provides excellent control, particularly suited to bluegrass and other styles requiring precision.
This pick’s excellent balance makes it suitable for intricate melodies and fast passages. The smooth surface contributes to a comfortable playing experience.
Jim Dunlop “Tried Tones” Jazz Pick
Finally, the Jim Dunlop “Tried Tones” jazz pick is a thick pick designed for archtop guitars and jazz playing. It offers a unique tonal profile.
Its thick design provides a substantial attack and a robust tone. The pick's bevel contributes to its distinctive sound, producing a full and rich tone suitable for both strumming and flatpicking.
This pick is a superb choice for jazz musicians who prefer a warm, thick tone on their archtop guitar. Its substantial weight contributes to excellent control and sustain.
Conclusion
Each pick offers a unique tonal character and playing experience. The choice depends greatly on personal preference and the desired sound. There's no single 'best' pick.
The Blue Chip picks provide excellent versatility, while the antique tortoiseshell and John Pierce offer unique warmth and character. The Dunlop Tortex excels in affordability and lightness.
The Wegen provides a more focused bluegrass tone, and the Dunlop jazz pick stands out for its suitability to jazz and archtop guitars. Experimentation is key to finding your perfect pick.