High-end guitar picks like Gravity are renowned for their superior quality, but their hefty price tag often leaves players searching for more budget-friendly alternatives. This comprehensive comparison pits Gravity picks against a range of Dunlop picks, examining whether affordable options can truly replicate the feel and performance of their premium counterparts. We delve into the nuances of thickness, stiffness, material composition, and grip, offering a detailed analysis to help you decide if the investment in a Gravity pick is justified, or if a more economical Dunlop pick can deliver comparable results.This review focuses specifically on a 6mm Gravity pick, comparing it to several Dunlop options to find the closest match in terms of thickness, stiffness, and overall playing experience. We assess the differences in material feel, exploring how factors like surface texture and grip contribute to playability and comfort. Ultimately, we aim to provide a clear and informative guide, enabling guitarists to make an informed decision based on their individual needs and budget constraints, weighing the premium feel of Gravity against the affordability and performance of Dunlop picks.
Pros And Cons
- Good grip
- Relatively inexpensive ($4 for a pack)
- Similar material and feel to Gravity picks
- May not be as thick as desired
- More flex than Gravity Picks
- Cheaper than Gravity Picks
- Same thickness (1.5mm) as Gravity pick
- Similar stiffness to Gravity pick
- Slicker than Gravity picks, may slip more easily
- Stiff, little flex
- Similar feel to Gibson nitro finishes
- Laser-cut name/design is permanent
- Expensive ($10-$14 plus shipping)
- Slick, may slip out of hand
- Only one pick included in purchase
Read more: 5 Best Celluloid Guitar Picks You Need to Try
The Price Point Dilemma
High-end guitar picks like Gravity can cost a pretty penny. A single 6mm Gravity pick, including shipping, can easily exceed $10. This price point makes it a significant investment for many players. The cost is a key factor influencing the search for more affordable alternatives.
On the other hand, budget-friendly options are readily available. Dunlop offers a wide range of picks at various price points, making them a more accessible choice for budget-conscious guitarists.
This comparison explores whether affordable options can replicate the feel and performance of premium picks like Gravity, offering a cost-effective solution without sacrificing quality.
Thickness and Flex Comparison
The Gravity pick used in the comparison is 6mm thick. The reviewer seeks a similar thickness in a more affordable option. Dunlop Derlin 1.5mm and Dunlop USA Heavy picks are tested.
The 1.5mm Dunlop Derlin pick matches the Gravity pick in thickness but is noticeably smaller in overall size. Its stiffness is similar to the Gravity, offering minimal flex.
The Dunlop USA Heavy pick, while thicker, shows more flex than the Gravity and the 1.5mm Derlin. A direct comparison with a 1.0mm Dunlop pick showcases the differences in flexibility among these picks.
Material and Grip
The Gravity pick’s material is described as having a slick, almost plasticky feel, potentially making it prone to slipping. The Dunlop Derlin pick shares a similar smooth surface.
The Dunlop USA Heavy pick’s material is described as having a warmer, smoother and more glassy feel and better grip compared to Gravity, making it less likely to slip from the fingers.
The reviewer emphasizes the importance of grip and highlights how the surface texture and material affect playability and handling.
Overall Assessment and Recommendations
For a Gravity pick alternative with similar thickness and stiffness, the Dunlop Derlin 1.5mm is recommended. The extra heavy Jim Dunlop pick is another option to provide the same thickness and stiffness with a better grip
Although the Gravity picks offer excellent quality, the cost is a significant factor. The reviewer concludes that the Dunlop options provide a viable and more budget-friendly alternative.
Ultimately, the choice depends on individual preferences and priorities. While Gravity's premium feel is undeniable, Dunlop's picks are a strong contender in terms of performance and affordability.