Choosing the right guitar pick can significantly impact your sound, especially when dealing with older, "dead" strings. This experiment dives deep into the subtle yet impactful differences between three popular picks: the Dunlop Tortex, Dunlop Prime Tone, and Graph Tech TUSQ. All three picks are tested at the same thickness (0.88mm) on two guitars with varying string ages – a Gibson J-50 with very old strings and a Collings D2H with relatively newer strings – to ensure a comprehensive analysis. The goal is to objectively determine if and how the material of each pick influences the overall tone produced, offering clear insights for guitarists seeking to refine their sound.This comparative study focuses on the tonal characteristics of each pick, comparing their performance against a baseline (no pick) to isolate their unique contributions. We examine the attack, brightness, and overall warmth delivered by each pick, considering the impact on both a vintage Gibson and a modern Collings guitar. The findings offer a valuable guide for guitarists looking to understand how pick material affects their sound and to make informed choices based on their personal preferences and playing styles.
Read more: 5 Best Celluloid Guitar Picks You Need to Try
Testing Methodology: Dead Strings and Two Guitars
This experiment aims to determine if the material of a guitar pick affects the tone, particularly with 'dead' strings. We'll use two guitars: a Gibson J-50 with extremely old strings (at least a year and a half old) and a Collings D2H with strings approximately five weeks old. Both sets of strings are considered 'dead' for the purpose of this test. This setup will give our picks multiple chances to reveal their sonic characteristics.
Three picks were selected: a Dunlop Tortex 0.88mm (plastic), a Dunlop Prime Tone 0.88mm (plastic), and a Graph Tech TUSQ (synthetic ivory). All picks are 0.88mm thick. Each pick's sound will be compared to the sound of the guitars with no pick to establish a baseline tone.
The testing process involved playing a short riff on each guitar with and without each pick. This methodology allows for an objective comparison of how each pick influences the tone of both instruments, irrespective of the guitars' inherent sounds.
Dunlop Tortex Pick Analysis
The Dunlop Tortex pick, known for its durability, demonstrated a certain clarity and punch. The material itself seemed to bring a distinct characteristic to the tone, although the exact nature would be subjective. Testing on both the Gibson J-50 and the Collings D2H revealed some consistency in its performance.
It provided a certain level of attack and brightness, which might appeal to players looking for a defined sound, even with dead strings. However, its overall contribution may vary based on the player's style and the specific guitar's characteristics. Further analysis considering different string gauges and playing styles might provide more detailed insights.
The Dunlop Tortex pick presents a balanced option, offering a good combination of clarity and durability for its price point. The absence of overt tonal coloration allows the natural resonance of the guitar to shine through.
Dunlop Prime Tone Pick Analysis
The Dunlop Prime Tone pick offered a slightly different experience compared to the Tortex. It exhibited a warmer, perhaps less aggressive tone. The tonal differences, while noticeable, were subtle, showcasing the impact of subtle material variations.
Its performance on both guitars was similarly consistent, reinforcing the idea of a slightly mellower sound compared to the Tortex. This might make it a good choice for players seeking a smoother, less aggressive tone, especially in genres where a less pronounced attack is preferred.
The Dunlop Prime Tone, while not as bright, presents a smooth, warm option for players who prioritize a less aggressive sound. This softer tone makes it a versatile pick suitable for various playing styles, while still offering durability.
Graph Tech TUSQ Pick Analysis
The Graph Tech TUSQ pick, with its synthetic ivory material, is marketed for its bright tone. In this comparison, it did indeed offer a brighter, more articulate sound than the other two picks. The difference was more pronounced on the Gibson J-50, likely due to its older strings.
The increased brightness and articulation could be beneficial for players looking for a brighter, crisper tone, particularly those who play fingerstyle or prefer a more defined sound, which is noticeable on the Gibson and Collings guitars.
The Graph Tech TUSQ offers a high-end option for players who prioritize brightness and clarity. Its synthetic ivory material delivers a unique articulation, however its price point makes it a pick for those seeking a premium feel and sound.
Conclusion and Overall Assessment
The experiment demonstrated that the pick material does subtly affect the tone, even with dead strings. Each pick had its own distinctive characteristics. The Dunlop Tortex provided a balanced sound; the Dunlop Prime Tone was warmer and less aggressive; and the Graph Tech TUSQ offered the brightest and most articulate tone.
The choice of pick will ultimately depend on personal preference and playing style. Players seeking a bright, clear sound may prefer the Graph Tech TUSQ, while those who prefer a warmer tone might choose the Dunlop Prime Tone. The Dunlop Tortex offers a versatile middle ground.
All three picks proved durable and functional. The price point should be considered, as the Graph Tech TUSQ was the most expensive pick tested. However, value is subjective depending on a player's needs and budget.