This article presents a seven-month comparison of Elixir Nanoweb and Polyweb guitar strings, both in 80/20 bronze. The review details the author's experience with each set, highlighting differences in tuning, feel, and sound quality over an extended period of use. One set of strings was a light gauge Nanoweb, the other a custom light gauge Polyweb, allowing for a direct comparison of Elixir's two coating technologies. The review doesn't focus solely on immediate impressions but provides a long-term perspective on durability, tone evolution, and overall playability, offering valuable insight for guitarists considering an upgrade to coated strings.The author directly compares the longevity, ease of tuning, and playing feel of both string types. While both sets delivered excellent sound quality, subtle differences in tone and texture emerged over the seven-month test period. This review will help you decide whether the smoother playability of the Polywebs or the familiar feel of the Nanowebs better suits your needs and playing style, ultimately aiding your decision on which coated string offers the best long-term value and performance.
Pros And Cons
- Slick feel
- Good sound quality
- Difficult to tune; requires significant stretching
- Good sound quality (even after eight months of use)
- Develop buildup and a ringing sound after extended use
- One B string snapped after five months
Read more: Top 5 Elixir Guitar Strings: A Buyer's Guide
Initial Impressions and Sound Quality After 8 Months
After using Elixir Nanoweb strings for approximately eight months, I noticed a slight build-up and a subtle ringing sound, especially as the strings were played. Despite this, the sound quality remained surprisingly good, demonstrating the strings' durability.
The wear and tear were visible but didn't significantly impact the overall tone. I observed a certain level of accumulated grime but the audible quality was still respectable for extended use.
Switching to Elixir Polyweb Strings
The transition to Elixir Polyweb strings proved challenging initially. Tuning these strings required significant effort and stretching. However, once properly tuned and settled, the feel was notably different—much smoother than the Nanowebs.
The difference in feel was immediately apparent. The Polywebs offered a slicker playing experience, although the initial tuning process was more demanding.
Comparison: Sound and Feel
Both sets of strings were the 80/20 bronze variety. The Nanowebs were light gauge, while the Polywebs were custom light. While there might be a slight difference due to the gauge, the sound distinction between the two was significant, although I wouldn’t attribute it entirely to the gauge difference.
The Polywebs appeared to have a thicker coating compared to the Nanowebs. The 7-month-old Nanowebs, despite a broken B string during tuning (a fairly typical occurrence), still held their own in a sound comparison. The newer Polywebs had a slightly different feel, making them easier to play, but the overall sound wasn't drastically different.
Sound Comparison and Conclusion
While both strings provided decent sound quality, a sound comparison highlights subtle differences that might influence your preference. The Polywebs had a distinct feel, but the Nanowebs offered slightly more familiar playability for me.
The choice between the Nanowebs and Polywebs comes down to personal preference. Consider trying both sets to determine which better suits your playing style and sound expectations. Overall, the differences are subtle enough that both strings offer an excellent upgrade over basic strings.
