This article details a head-to-head comparison of two popular guitar string brands: Ernie Ball Slinky and D'Addario NYXL. The author, experiencing unexpected stiffness and discomfort with their D'Addario NYXL strings on a Fender Telecaster Squire, decided to conduct a scientific test to determine the source of the problem. The investigation wasn't just about a subjective feeling; it sought to quantify the difference in string tension and bending ease between the two brands. The unexpected findings highlight the often-overlooked impact of string choice on playability and overall guitar performance.This comparative analysis goes beyond simply stating preference. Using a quantitative approach, the author measured the force required to bend the low E string on both string sets. The results reveal a tangible difference in tension, ultimately influencing the ease of bending and the overall playing experience. This detailed account offers valuable insight for guitarists seeking to optimize their setup and discover the best strings for their playing style and preferences, demonstrating that seemingly minor differences in string selection can dramatically impact playing comfort and enjoyment.
Pros And Cons
- Easier to bend
- Feel slinkier
Read more: Top 5 Elixir Guitar Strings: A Buyer's Guide
The Initial Problem: A Telecaster's Unhappy Feel
I recently experienced frustration with my Fender Telecaster Squire semi-hollow body guitar. Despite playing it regularly, it never felt as comfortable or responsive as my other guitars. I suspected an issue with the action or truss rod adjustment, leading me to a closer inspection.
Upon closer examination, I noticed something odd. The strings, a set of D'Addario NYXLs, were the culprit. The ball ends had a peculiar coloration, suggesting they weren't performing as expected.
This wasn't my usual string choice; I generally prefer Ernie Ball Slinkys due to their proven performance and feel. Something about these NYXL strings just wasn't working for me, despite the brand's good reputation.
The Bending Test: Quantifying String Feel
To objectively compare the string tension and bending ease, I devised a simple test. I used a scale to measure the force required to bend the low E string past the 21st fret.
The D'Addario NYXL strings required approximately 13-14 pounds of force to achieve this bend. This felt significantly stiffer than my usual experience.
The Ernie Ball Slinky Advantage
Switching back to Ernie Ball Slinkys, the difference was immediately apparent. The same bending test with the Slinkys required only around 12 pounds of force—a noticeable reduction in tension.
This confirmed my subjective feeling: Ernie Ball Slinkys were noticeably easier to bend and offered a more comfortable playing experience. The improved playability made a significant difference in overall enjoyment.
Conclusion: Slinkys Win the Bendability Battle
After a thorough comparison, the Ernie Ball Slinky strings proved superior in terms of bending ease and overall playing feel. While D'Addario NYXLs are undoubtedly high-quality strings, their increased tension made them less comfortable for my playing style.
The subjective difference was confirmed by the objective bending force measurements. For those prioritizing easy bending and a responsive feel, Ernie Ball Slinkys are the clear winner in this matchup.
The D'Addario NYXLs might suit players who prefer a tighter, more robust string feel. However, for my personal preference and style, the Ernie Ball Slinkys are superior.